This is an update version of my original blog which I have deleted. This blog is meant to create a more appropriate proposal that appeals to a wider spectrum than before. This system would be used by the site Overlords to elect admins. This is simply an idea which I wish to recieve feedback on. I simply wish to see how members would react to such a system going into effect.
I am writing this blog on behaf of many members who agree with me.
DSiPaint has had lots of Administrators over the years, some, have been good, others...far less than that.
Therefore, I propose a set system for the election of administration for the site. This system would allow members to be chosen who are truely deserving of their positions.
This is just an idea, but I do think a similar system should be put into place for the site:
#1: Look at the user's number of bans. If they have more than ten serious bans, they should be more closely watched when they are elcted admin.
#2: Look at the user's level of activity on the site. An administrator should be active on the site for at least for days a week.
#3 (in my opinion, the most crucial point) Observe said member for a week. Watch their level of maturity, and how they act in chat. Make sure that this member can be considered a role model. While many don't agree, this site's leadership should have a higher level of Maturity than most users. While Maturity for some positions doesn't matter (Paintmin/Saviimin etc. it does matter for Chatmid, Blogmin, and Secretary.
#4: Is the user often active in said field of the site? The user's promotion should match the area of the site that they are most active in.
#5: While biases do exist, current administrators should have the right to provide feedback, HOWEVER, the choice should not rest soley on the administrator's choice, but the one the the Overlords consider fit. The admins would not choose the people! They woiuld simply provide feedback on the user,
While I know a system may currently exist, I believe that it could be refined so that many more members of a higher maturity level could be elected to site leadership as role models, instead of "members with power".
As a final note/disclaimer:
This blog is not intentionally directed towards any admin, former admin, or member, and I did not intentionally mean to offend anyone. This is simply many members speaking out about something they wish should be done.
If you agree with this blog, please say so below, feedback is nessessary for all changes.
so if you hangout alot in the helpdesk cuz you know nothing about the site you should be a secretary.
And you are pretty much saying that the dull boring losers should be admins, i mean look at waffle king he's my favorite admin cuz he's fun and entertaining but still duz wuts rite.
WHO ARE YOU CALLING A PSYCHO POWER-HUNGRY CRIMINAL?
New admins every month is a terrible idea. It takes about a month for you to not only get the hang of being admin, but for the ban-happy bliss of finally getting admin to wear off. You're just saying "Oh boy, I want some fresh noobmins every month! I don't care how ban-happy they are!"
But, after reading other's comments, I am swayed. Watching people and there actions on this site? The overlords do have lives other than the online ones.
Not a good idea. HullBreach can't be on here to check on the votings 24/7 plus many people are just going to abuse their voting powers by voting for their friends and may not focus on the person's responsibility or maturity to be admin.
I honestly think we have enough admins as it is. This idea isn't that great,because the Overlords/Admins aren't full time stalkers like some of us. Let's just let things be. It's not like almost every admin here is some psycho, power-hungry criminal.
Great. Lets turn this website into a democratic system.
The government did that, and look what happened to us today!
I actually prefer a monarchy system, which we use now. There's a King and Queen (and a princess and Gigi). They will chose who gets to be an admin as needed, like Waffle King said.
Yup. Just another scheme to get admin powers. Let's let the people run the website, I'm sure Danny will agree to that -.-
this'll work...if there was a system that records everything everyone does when they are on. and even if there was i dont think hull would want to watch what most members do here
After reading some nicely said points from other people, it is true that the current system is quite fine and alls this'll do is load un-needed work on Hull. That and I see no benefits with having this system you're suggesting.
Exactly, Bane. These kids seem to think that an admin being made is something that happens as often as them wetting the bed. Admins are made when NEEDED. Is the ban list full? Are the blogs being checked? Then no, we don't need anymore admins. KTHNXBAI.
And the current system doesn't? No matter what, there will, as Darth Bane said, be popularity involved, this system just aims to make the people recommended more correctly tailored for their position.
Yeaaaah. Because Hull has NOTHING better to do than watch your every move. Didn't your parents have "the talk" with you, on how admins are made? Mommy Sav, Daddy Hull, and Crazy Uncle Skunk get together and say "Hmm... it seems like we need some more admins. This guy is responsible, he's always on, and he isn't a complete social reject. He'd make a great admin." And thus, an admin is born. That's it. We aren't running to be the damn president. We all know I'd win that election.
I believe in order to get noticed by the Overlords you need to be popular. As since they can't watch over everybody.
Also I just realized he said "popularity vote" so I take back on the fact that I said it was true, just popularity always takes a role in pretty much everything.