Old or New?

I like the older games, I even like the old music in the games too. That and the older games are what started it all.

Don't argue with idiots because they will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience.

i actually like newer games, most favorite soul silver, but there is still something pokemon company can't recreate about the old ones...

I put the fun in dysfunctional.

I like the newer Pokmon games also, but I could never throw away my old ones.

genius isn't everything

You can get several games in one and meet more Pokemon in new games like HeartGold and SoulSilver.

genius isn't everything

Emblem- Don't double post.

The new games are cool too, because of the better graphics and more features.

Don't argue with idiots because they will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience.

i like the older ones.

I dream of a better tomorrow, where chickens can cross the road and not be questioned about their motives.

i like the older ones better, they are classics

The old ones, by faaaaaar![u]
The only new games I like (considering 'new' is from D/P - B/W) are Pearl & HeartGold. Pearl because they Pokemon were unique, it first brought Pokerus & Ev Training to us & it was just completely, unexpected. However B/W to me, had great graphics but lacked in the addiction. The Pokemon are most edits of older forms (more specificly D/P) The only Pokemon from B/W I like are Oshawott & Minchino. Besides the names have just become serverly uncreative. I mean Gear? Tepig? C'mon! And the newer games only take [u]1 - 7 days to complete!
As for the old games, they had it all!
The unbeatable music, the creative names, the epic, unused storyline, the looks & the addiction (even if you completed it countless times!)
So who wins?
New games OLD ONES!
/endminiblog

People say DisneyLand's the best place in the world, they've clearly never been in your arms (B

@Nero: Moron... EV-Training has been around since Gen I, and PokeRus in Gen II. -.-

Also, older players find the new games easier because they're USED to the formula. Newer players take a bit longer, so it might seem unbalanced.

And what do you mean "most edits of older fprms[mre specifically D/P]"? If you mean the sprites for the OLDER Pokemon, do you expect them to redraw them every time? NO. And none of the newer Pokemon are related in any way to the old ones. Shall I continue pointing things out with your statement? I think I shall. The names have never been 100% perfect. The addiction is still with the new games, and the new ones brought better connectivity meaning more chance at completing that goddamn Pokedex.

Again, I repeat, moron. -.-

I personally like Gen II the most, specifically Crystal Version.

Whoa bro, better slow down bro, don't wanna be a bro, bro.

Old gen pwns

Two fails don't make a win... and three fails don't either. So no thinking about it kiddies xD

@Kion: MUTINY. >:U
Yes, I have 224 on my Crystal PokèDex, I still need Ninetails, Tyranitar, Dragonite, and... A few others, I have the old Starters in their Stage 1 forms, and the old Fossils. o3o

Whoa bro, better slow down bro, don't wanna be a bro, bro.

In any logical argument, the newer games win hands down, no chance. More features, better music, more Pokemon. When one accounts for the nostalgia effect, I still believe the newer games would win because--to me-- the effect of nostalgia, while powerful, does not overpower the betterness (I know it isn't a word) of the newer games.
As for my favorites, I'd have to say it's a tie between Black, Emerald, Crystal. :)

It's my job to help the next generation, and set a good example for them. And for that I'll gladly lay down my life.

@Skittles: Well, when it comes to Pokemon, where we fight with magical creatures, and train carps to turn into flying fish, I don't think logic exists anymore. :P
But true, the technological advances outshine previous ones... but sometimes, it's annoying when they leave out certain features that were excellent in past Gens, and could've come back in newer Gens...

Whoa bro, better slow down bro, don't wanna be a bro, bro.

Don't even. Until every single Pokemon game has been played, Pokemon hasn't been played. (Strange words coming from a lukewarm Pokemon fan.)

Catch my drift.

New And old are awsome!

Stare Much?

Ehhh...I'm neutral on this. I like both :/

Throwback to my cringey emo phase.

It all depends on what you first had, and how long ago.

Lots of [spoiled] little 2y/o's run around with 3DS' these days, so Gen IV or Gen V is completely new to them!

Whoa bro, better slow down bro, don't wanna be a bro, bro.

I love Pokemon Yellow, Crystal Blue, Leaf Green, Fire Red, Ruby, and Emearld.